Guest Reviews

“Absolutely loved our stay! The house was spotless, beautifully decorated, and perfectly located. We walked to restaurants and shops every day. Greg was incredibly responsive and helpful with recommendations. Already planning our return trip!”

“This house is a dream for family gatherings. We had 10 people and everyone had plenty of space. The wrap-around deck was our favorite spot for morning coffee. The kids loved the game room downstairs. Fish Creek is magical and this house made it even better.”

“Five stars is not enough. The location cannot be beat — right across from the Peninsula School of Art and a short walk to everything. The house is stocked with everything you need. Dan and Greg thought of every detail. Highly recommend booking direct!”

“We stayed for a week and did not want to leave. The three floors gave everyone their own space. The location is unbeatable — walking distance to everything in Fish Creek. Greg was an amazing host with great local tips.”

“We have been visiting Door County for 20 years and this is the best rental we have ever stayed in. The sun deck is incredible, the house is immaculate, and the location puts you right in the middle of everything Fish Creek has to offer.”

“A truly special place. We had three generations of our family together and everyone was comfortable. The kids could walk to the park, the grandparents loved the sun deck, and the parents appreciated the fully stocked kitchen.”

“Our second time staying at the Blue House and it was just as wonderful. The house is clean, well-maintained, and has everything you need. The fire pit is perfect for cool fall evenings. We will be back again next year!”

“What an incredible property. The open concept layout was perfect for our group of 10. We cooked breakfast every morning and grilled dinner every night. The location is phenomenal — everything is walkable. Greg and Dan are the best hosts.”

“The Blue House exceeded all our expectations. It is spacious, comfortable, and in the perfect location. Our kids loved having the lower level to themselves while the adults relaxed on the wrap-around deck. Already booked for next summer!”

“We celebrated our anniversary here and it was perfect. The house is beautifully maintained, the fire pit was a hit every evening, and being right across from the Peninsula School of Art made for wonderful morning walks. Thank you Greg and Dan!”

“A perfect week in Fish Creek. The bunk room was a huge hit with the kids, the kitchen had everything we needed for family meals, and we loved having three bathrooms with a big group. The house was exactly as described and then some.”

“Fall in Door County is magical, and this house was the perfect home base. The sun deck overlooking the fall colors was breathtaking. We walked to dinner every night and enjoyed the fire pit afterward. Cannot wait to return.”